What is the Difference Between Affinity and Ion Exchange Chromatography?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Affinity chromatography and ion exchange chromatography are two different techniques used for protein purification. The main differences between these two methods are:
- Principle: Affinity chromatography is based on specific binding interactions between molecules, such as antigen-antibody or enzyme-substrate interactions. In contrast, ion exchange chromatography separates molecules according to the strength of their overall ionic interaction with a solid phase material, which are nonspecific interactions.
- Specificity: Affinity chromatography is highly specific, as it relies on the binding of target molecules to a specific ligand that is chemically immobilized on a solid support. Ion exchange chromatography, on the other hand, is based on the charged nature of the molecules and their interaction with the stationary phase surface.
- Target Molecules: Affinity chromatography can be used to separate charged or uncharged components in a mixture, such as enzymes, substrates, DNA, antigens, proteins, and antibodies. Ion exchange chromatography is used to separate charged particles, like inorganic cations and anions, organic ions, and proteins.
- Column Interaction: In ion exchange chromatography, the target molecules have an opposite charge to that of the stationary phase surface. In affinity chromatography, the target molecules have a high affinity for the stationary phase due to specific interactions.
In summary, affinity chromatography and ion exchange chromatography are two distinct techniques used for protein purification, with affinity chromatography relying on specific binding interactions and ion exchange chromatography based on ionic interactions.
Comparative Table: Affinity vs Ion Exchange Chromatography
Affinity and ion exchange chromatography are two subcategories of liquid chromatographic techniques used to separate components in a mixture. Here is a table comparing the differences between the two:
Feature | Affinity Chromatography | Ion Exchange Chromatography |
---|---|---|
Basis | Separates based on specific interactions between the target and the stationary phase surface | Separates based on the interaction between the column and the target molecule that has an opposite charge |
Charged/Uncharged | Can be used to separate both charged and uncharged components in a mixture | Separates charged particles, such as inorganic cations, anions, organic ions, and proteins |
Examples | Enzymes, substrates, DNA, antigens, proteins, and antibodies | Inorganic cations and anions, organic ions, and proteins |
Stationary Phase | A particular ligand is chemically immobilized or "coupled" to a solid support | The solid phase has a fixed charge, which interacts with the target molecule's opposite charge |
Mobile Phase | The solution containing the mixture to be separated | The buffer conditions, such as ionic strength and pH, are manipulated to bind or dissociate molecules from the solid phase |
In summary, affinity chromatography is based on specific interactions between the target and the stationary phase surface, while ion exchange chromatography is based on the interaction between the column and the target molecule that has an opposite charge. Affinity chromatography can be used to separate both charged and uncharged components, whereas ion exchange chromatography is specifically for separating charged particles.
- Ion Pair vs Ion Exchange Chromatography
- Gel Filtration vs Affinity Chromatography
- Ion Exchange vs Size Exclusion Chromatography
- Adsorption vs Partition Chromatography
- Electrophoresis vs Chromatography
- Ionization Energy vs Electron Affinity
- Distillation vs Chromatography
- Affinity vs Avidity
- Gel Filtration vs Gel Permeation Chromatography
- Ion Exchange vs Reverse Osmosis
- Electronegativity vs Electron Affinity
- Cation Exchange Capacity vs Anion Exchange Capacity
- Gas Solid Chromatography vs Gas Liquid Chromatography
- Gas Chromatography vs Mass Spectrometry
- Chromatofocusing vs Isoelectric Focusing
- Ionization vs Electrolysis
- Zeolite vs Ion Exchange Process
- Ionization vs Dissociation
- Chemisorption vs Physisorption