What is the Difference Between Carbonium Ion and Carbanion?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The key difference between a carbonium ion and a carbanion is the valence and charge of the carbon atom. Here are the main differences between the two:
- Carbonium Ion: The carbon atom in a carbonium ion is pentavalent, meaning it has five covalent bonds. The geometry around the carbon atom is planar. Carbonium ions are positively charged species and are known as carbocations.
- Carbanion: The carbon atom in a carbanion is trivalent, meaning it has three covalent bonds. The geometry of the carbon atom in a carbanion can be trigonal pyramidal, bent, or linear, depending on the substituents. Carbanions are negatively charged species and are known as nucleophiles.
In summary, carbonium ions have a positive charge and a pentavalent carbon atom, while carbanions have a negative charge and a trivalent carbon atom. The geometry around the carbon atom is planar for carbonium ions and can vary for carbanions depending on the substituents.
Comparative Table: Carbonium Ion vs Carbanion
The key difference between a carbonium ion and a carbanion lies in the valency and charge of the carbon atom. Here is a comparison table highlighting the differences:
Feature | Carbonium Ion | Carbanion |
---|---|---|
Charge | +1 (positive) | -1 (negative) |
Valency | 5 (pentavalent) | 2 (trivalent) |
Geometry | Planar | Trigonal pyramidal, bent, or linear (depending on substituents) |
Electron Pair | 3 bonds, 1 lone pair | 2 bonds, 1 unshared pair |
Basicity | No | Yes, basic and nucleophilic |
Reactivity | Low | Highly reactive |
A carbonium ion has a carbon atom with a positive charge and five valence electrons (pentavalent), while a carbanion has a carbon atom with a negative charge and two valence electrons (trivalent). Carbonium ions are less reactive than carbanions, which are highly reactive and nucleophilic.
- Carbocation vs Carbanion
- Carbene vs Carbanion
- Carbonyl vs Carboxyl
- Carbonic Acid vs Bicarbonate
- Carbonic Acid vs Carbolic Acid
- Carbonyl vs Ketone
- Hydronium Ion vs Hydrogen Ion
- Carbonate vs Bicarbonate
- Anion vs Cation
- Isotope vs Ion
- Free Radical vs Ion
- Atom vs Ion
- Atom vs Ion
- Hydrogen Atom vs Hydrogen Ion
- Positive vs Negative Ion
- Protonation vs Ionization
- Carbon Dioxide vs Carbon Monoxide
- Polyatomic Ions vs Compounds
- Acetylacetone vs Acetylacetonate Ion