What is the Difference Between Colles Fracture and Smith Fracture?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The main difference between a Colles fracture and a Smith fracture lies in the direction of the bone displacement. Both fractures occur in the distal end of the radius, one of the two forearm bones, but they result in different bone fragment orientations:
- Colles Fracture: This fracture occurs when the radius breaks and the broken end is displaced upward, towards the back of the hand. It is the most common type of distal radius fracture and typically results from falling on an outstretched hand with the wrist bent back.
- Smith Fracture: Also known as a reverse Colles fracture, this fracture occurs when the broken end of the radius is displaced downward, towards the palm side of the wrist. It is less common than a Colles fracture and usually occurs due to falling on a flexed hand or experiencing another trauma while the wrist is bent or flexed.
Both fractures have similar symptoms, including pain, swelling, and tenderness in the surrounding tissue, and may result in an unnatural wrist position depending on the severity of the fracture. Diagnosis of both fractures is based on a medical evaluation and X-ray imaging.
Comparative Table: Colles Fracture vs Smith Fracture
Here is a table comparing Colles Fracture and Smith Fracture:
Feature | Colles Fracture | Smith Fracture |
---|---|---|
Definition | A Colles fracture is a distal radius fracture with dorsal displacement of the broken fragment, resulting in the bone fragment bending towards the back of the hand. | A Smith fracture, also known as a reverse Colles fracture, is a distal radius fracture with volar displacement of the broken fragment, resulting in the bone fragment bending towards the palm side of the wrist. |
Causes | Colles fractures are typically caused by falling on an outstretched hand with the wrist bent back. | Smith fractures are often caused by falling on a flexed hand or from a hard hit. |
Symptoms | Pain, swelling, visibly displaced fragment, and loss of movement. | Pain, swelling, visibly displaced fragment, and loss of movement. |
Diagnosis | Diagnosis is based on a medical evaluation and X-ray examination. | Diagnosis is based on a medical evaluation and X-ray examination. |
Incidence | Colles fractures are the most common type of distal radius fracture. | Smith fractures make up approximately 5% of all combined radial and ulnar fractures. |
Classification | Colles fractures can be classified into three types based on the location and angle of the fracture. | Smith fractures can be classified into three types based on the location and angle of the fracture. |
In summary, the main difference between a Colles fracture and a Smith fracture is the direction of displacement of the broken fragment of the radius bone. A Colles fracture results in dorsal displacement, while a Smith fracture results in volar displacement.
- Sprain vs Fracture
- Cleavage vs Fracture
- Fracture vs Break
- Shin Splint vs Stress Fracture
- Intracapsular vs Extracapsular Fracture of Neck of Femur
- Osteoporosis vs Scoliosis
- Synchondrosis vs Symphysis
- Spondylosis vs Spondylolisthesis
- Anterolisthesis vs Spondylolisthesis
- Tibia vs Fibula
- Fission vs Fragmentation
- Freeze Fracture vs Freeze Etching
- Osteogenesis Imperfecta vs Osteoporosis
- Osteophytes vs Syndesmophytes
- Compact vs Cancellous Bone
- Collagen vs Keratin
- Cartilage vs Ligament
- Laceration vs Contusion
- Collagen vs Elastin