What is the Difference Between Delocalization and Resonance?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Delocalization and resonance are related chemical concepts, but they have distinct meanings. Here are the key differences between them:
- Delocalization:
- Refers to the distribution of electrons throughout an entire area, allowing them to spread out.
- Occurs in molecules with alternative single bonds, double bonds, or triple bonds, or in molecules with movable electrical charges.
- Can be thought of as a result or characteristic of resonance, but it may also refer to electron movements within solid-state metals, which is not quite resonance.
- Resonance:
- Refers to the movement of electrons within a molecule.
- It is a mental exercise and method within the Valence Bond Theory of bonding that describes the delocalization of electrons.
- Resonance structures are used when one Lewis structure for a single molecule cannot fully describe the molecule's bonding and electron distribution.
- The net sum of valid resonance structures is defined as a resonance hybrid, which represents the overall delocalization of electrons within the molecule.
In summary, delocalization refers to the distribution of electrons throughout a molecule, while resonance is a method used to describe the delocalization of electrons and the multiple possible Lewis structures that a molecule can have. Resonance structures are often used to explain the delocalization of electrons in molecules.
Comparative Table: Delocalization vs Resonance
The key difference between delocalization and resonance is that delocalization refers to electrons being distributed throughout the entire molecule, while resonance refers to the movement of electrons within a molecule.
Here is a table comparing the two concepts:
Delocalization | Resonance |
---|---|
Refers to electrons being distributed throughout the entire molecule | Refers to the movement of electrons within a molecule |
Occurs in molecules having alternative single bonds and double bonds or triple bonds, or molecules having movable electrical charges | Used to describe two or more possible Lewis structures that can represent a particular molecule |
The actual structure of the molecule is the resonance hybrid, which represents the overall delocalization of electrons within the molecule | A molecule with resonance has multiple bonds that can be placed in different positions without moving the individual atoms in the molecule |
Delocalization can be thought of as a result or characteristic of resonance, but it may also refer to electrons' movements within solid-state metals, which is not quite resonance | Resonance occurs between nonbonded electrons and the partially filled atomic orbitals of adjacent atoms |
In summary, delocalization and resonance are related chemical concepts, but they describe different aspects of electron distribution and movement within molecules.
- Hyperconjugation vs Resonance
- Conjugation vs Resonance
- Isomers vs Resonance
- Resonance vs Tautomerism
- Inductive Effect vs Resonance Effect
- Canonical Structure vs Resonance Hybrid
- Localized vs Delocalized Electrons
- Resonance vs π Conjugation
- Resonance vs Mesomeric Effect
- Resonance vs Natural Frequency
- Localised vs Delocalised Chemical Bonds
- Fermi Resonance vs Overtones in IR Spectra
- Dissociation vs Solvation
- Molecular Orbital Theory vs Hybridization Theory
- Regioselectivity vs Stereoselectivity
- Synthesis Reaction vs Dissociation Reaction
- Hybridized vs Unhybridized Orbitals
- Hybrid vs Degenerate Orbitals
- Dipole Dipole vs Dispersion