What is the Difference Between Gripe Water and Mylicon?

Gripe water and Mylicon are both used to help relieve gas and colic symptoms in babies, but they have different compositions and levels of approval. Here are the main differences between the two:

Gripe Water:

• Gripe water is considered a natural herbal remedy.
• It is not approved by the FDA for treating gas.
• The Poison Control Center advises against using herbal supplementation in infants.
• Contains sodium bicarbonate and various herbs such as ginger, chamomile, cardamom, licorice, cinnamon, clove, dill, lemon balm, or peppermint.
• Some gripe water products may have a soothing effect on a baby's stomach.

Mylicon:

• Mylicon is an FDA-approved medication.
• Uses simethicone as its active ingredient, which works by breaking down the surface of gas bubbles, helping the baby's natural process of getting rid of gas.
• Safe for use with newborns.
• Generally recommended for babies with gas pain symptoms such as pulling their legs towards their stomach, crying after feeding, spitting up frequently, or having a bloated belly.

While there is no guarantee that either remedy will work, some general guidelines suggest that if a baby's symptoms seem to stem more from gas pain, then gas drops like Mylicon might be more effective. If a baby appears in more general discomfort, gripe water might be the better option. However, it is always best to consult your pediatrician before using any remedy for your baby.

Comparative Table: Gripe Water vs Mylicon

Here is a table summarizing the main differences between gripe water and Mylicon:

Gripe water is a natural herbal remedy containing sodium bicarbonate and various herbs, while Mylicon is an FDA-approved medication with simethicone as its active ingredient. Mylicon is specifically designed to relieve symptoms of extra gas caused by air swallowing or other factors, and it has a safe and standardized dosage. In contrast, gripe water has no standard doses, and its effectiveness and safety have not been supported by sufficient studies. The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend the use of gripe water for babies due to the lack of proven benefits and potential risks. It is always advisable to consult a pediatrician before administering any remedy to your baby.