What is the Difference Between Inactivated and Recombinant Flu Vaccine?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The main difference between inactivated and recombinant flu vaccines lies in the production process and the components of the vaccines. Here are the key differences:
- Production Process: Inactivated flu vaccines are produced using an egg-based manufacturing process, which has been used for more than 70 years. In contrast, recombinant flu vaccines are created synthetically using recombinant technology, without the need for chicken eggs.
- Components: Inactivated flu vaccines contain killed influenza viruses or their components, such as viral proteins. Recombinant flu vaccines, on the other hand, do not use the flu virus or chicken eggs in their production. Instead, they are produced by isolating a specific gene from a naturally occurring "wild type" recommended vaccine virus and combining it with a baculovirus.
- Egg-Free: Recombinant flu vaccines are considered egg-free, making them a suitable option for individuals with egg allergies.
- Potential Benefits: Recombinant flu vaccines have some possible advantages over inactivated flu vaccines, such as being independent of the selection of vaccine viruses adapted for growth in eggs and avoiding mutations that can occur when viruses are grown in eggs. This can sometimes affect the effectiveness of the finished vaccine.
Both inactivated and recombinant flu vaccines are designed to provide protection against influenza, but they differ in their production methods and components. The choice of which vaccine to receive depends on individual preferences and recommendations from healthcare providers.
Comparative Table: Inactivated vs Recombinant Flu Vaccine
Here is a table comparing the differences between inactivated and recombinant flu vaccines:
Feature | Inactivated Flu Vaccine | Recombinant Flu Vaccine |
---|---|---|
Production Method | Egg-based or cell-based | Synthetic (recombinant technology) |
Virus Source | Chicken eggs or animal cells | No egg or cell culture required |
Vaccine Type | Injected into the deltoid muscle | Injected into the deltoid muscle |
Efficacy | Takes up to two weeks to be protected | Potentially more effective than standard dose unadjuvanted flu vaccines in certain age groups |
Antigen Production | Virus is grown in eggs or animal cells, then inactivated | Antigen is produced from a recombinant baculovirus, which does not require an egg-grown vaccine virus |
Advantages | Traditional vaccine, used for more than 70 years | Produced without using chicken eggs or cells, may offer better protection |
Disadvantages | Dependent on egg or cell culture, can be limited by vaccine viruses adapted for growth in eggs |
Inactivated flu vaccines are produced using either egg-based or cell-based technology, while recombinant flu vaccines are produced synthetically using recombinant technology. Inactivated vaccines require the use of chicken eggs or animal cells, whereas recombinant vaccines do not. Recombinant flu vaccines have the potential to be more effective than standard dose unadjuvanted flu vaccines in certain age groups.
- Live Attenuated vs Inactivated Vaccines
- DNA Vaccine vs Recombinant Vaccine
- Trivalent vs Quadrivalent Flu Vaccine
- Pneumococcal Vaccine vs Flu Vaccine
- Inoculation vs Vaccination
- Vaccine vs Injection
- Recombinant vs Nonrecombinant
- Viral Vector vs mRNA Vaccines
- Influenza A vs B
- DNA vs RNA Vaccines
- Flu vs H1N1
- Swine Flu vs Normal Flu
- Active vs Passive Immunity
- Bivalent vs Trivalent Polio Vaccine
- Cold vs Influenza
- Coronavirus vs Influenza
- mRNA vs Adenovirus Vaccine
- Vaccination vs Immunization
- Flu A vs B