What is the Difference Between Mohr Volhard and Fajans Method?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The Mohr, Volhard, and Fajans methods are analytical techniques used for precipitation reactions in chemistry. The main differences between these methods are:
- Mohr Method:
- Reaction between silver ion and halide ion in the presence of chromate indicator.
- Based on the formation of a precipitate using a chromate.
- Potassium chromate is used as an indicator.
- Volhard Method:
- Reaction between excess silver ions and halide ions.
- Relys on the formation of a complex with thiocyanate ions using an iron(III) ion.
- Ferric ammonium sulfate is used as an indicator.
- Fajans Method:
- Adsorption reaction between silver halide and fluorescein.
- Involves the adsorption of a colored indicator onto the surface of a precipitate.
In summary, the Mohr method is based on the reaction between silver ion and halide ion in the presence of chromate indicator, the Volhard method refers to the reaction between excess silver ions and halide ions, and the Fajans method involves the adsorption of a colored indicator onto the surface of a precipitate.
Comparative Table: Mohr Volhard vs Fajans Method
Here is a table comparing the Mohr, Volhard, and Fajans methods:
Method | Description | Indicator | Application |
---|---|---|---|
Mohr | Reaction between silver ion and halide ion in the presence of chromate indicator | Potassium chromate | Determination of chloride ions, mainly in pharmaceutical and environmental analysis |
Volhard | Reaction between excess silver ions and halide ions, forming acomplex with thiocyanate ions | Ferric ammonium sulfate | Determination of halide ions, including Br− and I−, in various applications |
Fajans | Adsorption reaction between silver halide and fluorescein | No indicator used | Determination of halide ions, particularly Cl−, Br−, and I− ions in solutions |
The main difference between the Mohr and Volhard methods is the indicator used and the reaction involved. The Mohr method uses potassium chromate as an indicator and involves the reaction between silver ions and halide ions in the presence of chromate indicator. On the other hand, the Volhard method uses ferric ammonium sulfate as an indicator and involves the reaction between excess silver ions and halide ions, forming a complex with thiocyanate ions.
The Fajans method, on the other hand, is based on the adsorption reaction between silver halide and fluorescein, and it does not use an indicator. This method is used for the determination of halide ions, particularly chloride, bromide, and iodide ions, in a solution.
- Fraunhofer vs Fresnel Diffraction
- Hartree vs Hartree-Fock Method
- Job’s Method vs Mole Ratio Method
- MOF vs COF
- Manner vs Method
- Methods vs Techniques
- Schottky Defect vs Frenkel Defect
- Hofmann vs Curtius Rearrangement
- Saytzeff vs Hofmann Rule
- Finkelstein vs Swarts Reaction
- Holliday Model vs Meselson-Radding Model
- Dumas vs Kjeldahl Method
- Fischer Projection vs Haworth Projection
- Hall Héroult Process vs Hoopes Process
- Ion Electron Method vs Oxidation Number Method
- Sandmeyer Reaction vs Gattermann Reaction
- Bohr vs Schrodinger Model
- Ferromagnetism vs Ferrimagnetism
- Approach vs Method