The difference between revision and editing lies in their focus and the stages of the writing process they involve. Here is a breakdown of the differences:
Revision:
- Focuses on the content, structure, and organization of the text.
- Makes major changes to the document, such as modifying the controlling ideas, adding new information, moving around paragraphs, or removing unnecessary information.
- Deals with the paper as a whole, considering strengths and weaknesses, arguments, focus, organization, support, and voice, as well as mechanical issues.
- Typically occurs before editing.
- Involves rewriting entire sections of the paper for the purpose of improving the content.
Editing:
- Focuses on sentence-level changes, such as sentence structure and phrasing.
- Makes local changes, like correcting spelling, grammar, punctuation, or word choice.
- Rearranges words in sentences, substitutes less precise or effective words with more precise and effective ones, and deletes unnecessary words.
- Occurs after the major content and structural changes have been made.
- Focuses primarily on sentence-level issues like sentence variety and word choice.
In summary, revision deals with the overall content, structure, and organization of a text, while editing involves making more local changes to improve sentence structure, phrasing, and other language elements. Revision typically comes before editing in the writing process.
Comparative Table: Revision vs Editing
Here is a table that highlights the differences between revision and editing:
Aspect | Revision | Editing |
---|---|---|
Focus | Content, organization, strengths, weaknesses, arguments, focus, and structure | Sentence-level issues, grammar, spelling, punctuation, and word choice |
Level | Holistic view of the writing | Focused on specific details and mechanics |
Process | Deals with the paper as a whole | Addresses problems on a sentence-level |
Dialogue-based | Involves questions and discussion between the writer and the reader | One-sided, with the editor providing comments and corrections |
Hierarchy | Non-hierarchical | Hierarchical, with the editor having the final say |
Objective | To expand and clarify ideas, challenge arguments, and improve the writing process | To correct mistakes and ensure proper grammar, spelling, and punctuation |
In summary, revising focuses on the content, organization, and overall structure of the writing, while editing concentra
Read more
- Revision vs Editing
- Editing vs Proofreading
- Modification vs Revision
- Review vs Revise
- Appeal vs Revision
- Publisher vs Editor
- Editorial vs Article
- Critique vs Review
- Sound Editing vs Sound Mixing
- Edition vs Issue
- Research Article vs Review Article
- Editorial vs Letter to the Editor
- Modify vs Change
- Critique vs Criticism
- Reproof vs Correction
- Journalism vs Creative Writing
- Editorial vs Opinion
- Writing vs Reading
- Review vs Audit
- Genetic Engineering vs Genome Editing