What is the Difference Between Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect?

The Schottky defect and Frenkel defect are both point defects that occur in ionic solids, but they differ in the way they affect the lattice structure and the composition of the solid. Here are the main differences between the two defects:

Defect Type:

Schottky defect: Equal numbers of cation and anion vacancies are created in the lattice, leading to a decrease in the density of the solid. This defect occurs in ionic crystals where the difference in size between cation and anion is small.
Frenkel defect: A cation moves from its lattice site to an interstitial site, creating a vacancy at the original site and a self-interstitial defect. This defect is common in ionic crystals where the anion is larger than the cation.

Vacancies and Interstitial Defects:

Schottky defect: Two vacancies are formed for each defect, and two atoms permanently leave the crystal.
Frenkel defect: One vacancy and one self-interstitial defect are created for each defect, and the number of atoms in the crystal remains the same.

Density of the Solid:

Schottky defect: The density of the solid decreases due to the formation of vacancies.
Frenkel defect: The density of the solid remains the same, as no atom leaves the crystal.

In summary, Schottky defects involve the absence of both cations and anions from their regular lattice sites, resulting in lattice vacancies, while Frenkel defects occur when a cation moves to an interstitial site, leaving behind a vacancy at its original lattice position. Both defects are examples of point defects in ionic solids and can influence the physical properties of the material.

On this page

What is the Difference Between Schottky Defect and Frenkel Defect?

Comparative Table: Schottky Defect vs Frenkel Defect

The main differences between Schottky and Frenkel defects are as follows:

Feature	Schottky Defect	Frenkel Defect
Formation	Occurs when oppositely charged atoms (cation and anion) leave their corresponding lattice sites, creating a pair of vacancy defects.	Occurs when an ion leaves its original lattice site and occupies an interstitial position, creating one vacancy and one self-interstitial defect.
Vacancies	One Schottky defect leads to the formation of two vacancies.	One Frenkel defect creates one vacancy and one self-interstitial defect.
Atom Displacement	Two atoms reduce from the crystal for each Schottky defect.	The number of atoms present in the crystal before and after Frenkel defect remains the same, as atoms leave the original lattice site and occupy interstitial position, residing within the solid crystal.
Density	Due to vacancy formation, Schottky defect reduces the density of the solid.	Density of the solid crystal before and after Frenkel defect remains the same, as no atom leaves the lattice.
Common Materials	Schottky defect can be found in ionic crystals where the difference in size between cation and anion is small.	Frenkel defect usually occurs in ionic crystals where the size of the anion is quite large.
Ion Migration	In Schottky defect, both cation and anion leave the solid crystal.	In Frenkel defect, only the smaller ion (cation) leaves its original lattice site, whereas the anion remains in its original lattice sites.

In summary, Schottky defects involve the creation of vacancies when oppositely charged atoms leave their lattice sites, while Frenkel defects involve the migration of ions to interstitial sites without changing the overall density of the crystal lattice.

Guilherme Mazui

Guilherme Mazui is graduated in journalism from the Federal University of Minas Gerais (UFMG) and a master's degree in Communication from the University of São Paulo (USP). In addition, he has experience in advertising writing and has worked as a content editor in several companies.