What is the Difference Between Simazine and Atrazine?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Simazine and atrazine are both herbicides in the class of triazine compounds, but they have different properties and uses. Here are the key differences between them:
- Solubility: Simazine is weakly soluble in water and more sediment-bound, while atrazine is moderate to highly water-soluble. This difference in solubility affects their transportation and environmental impact.
- Weed Control: Simazine is used to control broad-leaved weeds and annual grasses, while atrazine is used to prevent pre-emerging broadleaf weeds in crops. Both herbicides are effective against certain weeds, but their specific modes of action may vary.
- Application: Both simazine and atrazine are registered for use in turfgrass systems, such as golf courses, athletic fields, residential/commercial lawns, and sod farms. However, recent regulatory changes have affected their use patterns. For instance, atrazine's label has been modified to remove roadside use sites, conifer uses, and certain buffer requirements for ground and aerial applications.
- Environmental Impact: Research has shown that atrazine is more readily transported via surface runoff compared to simazine. This difference in transportation may affect the choice of herbicide to use near surface waters, with simazine potentially being a better choice in such situations.
On this pageWhat is the Difference Between Simazine and Atrazine? Comparative Table: Simazine vs Atrazine
Comparative Table: Simazine vs Atrazine
Here is a table comparing the differences between simazine and atrazine:
Property | Simazine | Atrazine |
---|---|---|
Chemical Formula | C7H12ClN5 | Unspecified |
Molar Mass | 201.66 g/mol | Unspecified |
Appearance | White crystalline powder | Unspecified |
Water Solubility | Weakly soluble | Moderate to highly water-soluble |
Sediment-bound | More sediment-bound | Less sediment-bound |
Usage | Controls broad-leaved weeds and annual grasses | Prevents pre-emerging broadleaf weeds in crops |
Pre-emergent or Post-emergent | Both, but more post-emergent | Both, but more post-emergent |
Photosynthetic Inhibitor | Yes | Yes |
Effect on Grasses | Can stunt tolerant grasses, but less harsh than atrazine | Can stunt tolerant grasses, but more harsh than simazine |
Application Rate (per acre) | 3 to 4 quarts | 2 quarts |
Restricted Use Permit | Not required | Required |
Simazine and atrazine are both herbicides in the class of triazine compounds, but they have different properties and uses. Simazine is weakly soluble in water and more sediment-bound, while atrazine is moderate to highly water-soluble and less sediment-bound. Simazine is used to control broad-leaved weeds and annual grasses, whereas atrazine is used to prevent pre-emerging broadleaf weeds in crops. Both herbicides are photosynthetic inhibitors, but atrazine seems to be more harsh on grasses than simazine.
Read more:
- Herbicide vs Insecticide
- Glyphosate vs Glufosinate
- Imidazole vs Triazole
- Insecticides vs Pesticides
- Malathion vs Parathion
- Fungicides vs Pesticides
- Butachlor vs Pretilachlor
- Imidazolidinyl Urea vs Diazolidinyl Urea
- Borazine vs Benzene
- Auxin vs Cytokinin
- Azotobacter vs Azospirillum
- Arsenic vs Arsine
- Auxin Gibberellin vs Cytokinin
- Aniline vs Acetanilide
- Azomethines vs Ketimines
- Auxin vs Gibberellin
- Biological Control vs Chemical Control
- Dimethicone vs Simethicone
- Trichlor vs Dichlor