What is the Difference Between Structuralism and Formalism?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Structuralism and Formalism are two literary theories or literary criticisms that focus on the structure of a particular text. However, they have different approaches and assumptions:
Structuralism:
- Analyzes universal, underlying structures in a text.
- Assumes that every text has a universal, underlying structure.
- Connects the work of a particular author with works of similar structures.
- Interested in the "big picture" of literature and the structure of literature.
- Closer to semiotics, linguistics, and philosophy.
Formalism:
- Analyzes the genre, mode, form, and discourse while rejecting bibliographical, cultural, historical, and social contexts.
- Focuses on the form of the text and the "literariness" of the text.
- Does not search inside texts for ideas from the outside world or about the authors themselves.
- Origin of many other literary criticism theories such as structuralism, post-structuralism, and deconstruction.
- Study of a text without taking into account any outside influence.
In summary, the key difference between structuralism and formalism is that structuralism focuses on the universal, underlying structures of a text and connects it with other literary works, while formalism analyzes the text's form, genre, mode, and discourse without considering external factors.
Comparative Table: Structuralism vs Formalism
Structuralism and Formalism are two literary theories that focus on the structure of a particular text. Here is a table comparing the key differences between the two:
Feature | Structuralism | Formalism |
---|---|---|
Focus | Universal, underlying structure of texts | Structure of a text without considering external factors such as social and cultural influence |
Assumption | All literary works have a universal structure | Literary works have unique structures |
Approach | Relates literary texts to a larger structure (e.g., intertextual connections, genres, recurrent patterns) | Analyzes literary devices within the text |
Influence | Influenced by Swiss linguist Ferdinand de Saussure | Influenced by Russian Formalism, which was in turn influenced by linguistic theory of Ferdinand de Saussure |
Connection | Structuralism is considered the philosophical foundation of Formalism | Formalism is a more objective and scientific approach to literary criticism |
Both theories are interested in the structure of literature, but Structuralism aims to identify a universal structure underlying all texts, while Formalism focuses on the unique structure of individual texts without considering external factors such as social and cultural influence.
- Structuralism vs Functionalism
- Post-Structuralism vs Structuralism
- Constructivism vs Constructionism
- Functionalism vs Behaviorism
- Positivism vs Constructivism
- Idealism vs Naturalism
- Functionalism vs Neofunctionalism
- Constructivism vs Social Constructivism
- Modernism vs Postmodernism
- Constructivism vs Cognitivism
- Idealism vs Materialism
- Formal vs Informal
- Functionalism vs Conflict Theory
- Pragmatism vs Idealism
- Positivism vs Interpretivism
- Positivism vs Logical Positivism
- Monism vs Dualism
- Realism vs Naturalism
- Molecular Formula vs Structural Formula