What is the Difference Between Tyler Model and Taba Model?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The Tyler model and the Taba model are both curriculum development models, but they differ in their approaches and emphasis. The key differences between the two models are:
- Approach: Tyler's model is deductive, while Taba's model is inductive. Tyler's model argues from the administrator's approach, while Taba's model reflects the teacher's approach.
- Linearity: Both models are linear in design, but the Tyler model contains four basic components (objectives, selection of learning experiences, organization of learning experiences, and evaluation), whereas the Taba model consists of seven steps.
- Focus: The Tyler model focuses on offering freedom for students to select what they learn, whereas the Taba model offers the opportunity for teachers to develop the curriculum. In the Taba model, teachers can identify the needs of the students, and the curriculum should be developed according to the needs and levels of the students.
- Engagement: Active engagement and interaction of students are encouraged by the theories of the Tyler model, while the Taba model encourages interactive activities within the classroom.
In summary, the Tyler model is a linear, deductive model that emphasizes the administrator's approach and student freedom, while the Taba model is an inductive, more flexible approach that focuses on the teacher's role in curriculum development and meeting students' needs.
Comparative Table: Tyler Model vs Taba Model
The Tyler and Taba models are both curriculum development models, but they differ in their approach and emphasis. Here is a table summarizing the differences between the two models:
Feature | Tyler Model | Taba Model |
---|---|---|
Developed by | Ralph Tyler | Hilda Taba |
Linearity | Linear, with four components: objectives, selection of learning experiences, organization of learning experiences, and evaluation | Non-linear, with seven steps |
Focus | Teacher-led organization of learning experiences | Collaborative and flexible, focusing on student needs and interests |
Student Involvement | Freedom for students to select what they learn | Teachers developing the curriculum based on students' needs and levels |
Active Engagement | Encourages active engagement and interaction of students | Encourages interactive activities within the classroom |
Opportunity for Exploration | Gives students great opportunities to explore their own interests | Offers opportunities for teacher interaction in class activities |
In summary, the Tyler model is a more linear, objective-focused approach that emphasizes the teacher-led organization of learning experiences, while the Taba model is more collaborative and flexible, focusing on student needs and interests. The choice of which model to use depends on the curriculum's context and goals.
- Model vs Theory
- Make vs Model
- Tyler vs Wheeler Model of Curriculum
- Model vs Supermodel
- Model vs Framework
- Classification vs Tabulation
- Waterfall Model vs V Model
- Waterfall vs Spiral Model
- Static vs Dynamic Modelling
- Bohr vs Quantum Model
- TDP vs TDT
- Modelling vs Simulation
- Cost Model vs Revaluation Model
- Talmud vs Torah
- Tabtech M009S vs Apple iPad 2
- TGA DTA vs DSC
- Paradigm vs Theory
- Power Series vs Taylor Series
- Holliday Model vs Meselson-Radding Model